COMPANY 1. USAA 2. Geico 3. State Farm 4. Erie 5. Travelers 6. Auto-Owners 7. Nationwide 8. Progressive 9. Allstate 10. Farmers | AVERAGE ANNUAL $1,141 $1,182 $1,402 $1,419 $1,435 $1,532 $1,540 $1,892 $2,022 $2,124 | AVERAGE MONTHLY $95 $99 $117 $118 $120 $128 $128 $158 $169 $177 |